| November 15, 2039 |  @ Troy Trojans | L 48-79 | 0-1 | J. Steele 17 | J. Watkins 3 | D. Gelbard 8 |
| November 18, 2039 |  VMI KEYDETS | W 92-68 | 1-1 | R. Sullivan 15 | J. Watkins 6 | D. Gelbard 7 |
| November 22, 2039 |  KANSAS CITY KANGAROOS | L 67-73 | 1-2 | J. Steele 13 | K. Fleming 5 | J. Steele 9 |
| November 25, 2039 |  ST. THOMAS TOMMIES | L 66-85 | 1-3 | K. Fleming 19 | J. Watkins 6 | G. DeWolfe 7 |
| November 28, 2039 |  SIU EDWARDSVILLE COUGARS | L 75-79 | 1-4 | S. Poge 12 | R. Sullivan 4 | R. Sullivan 6 |
| December 3, 2039 |  JACKSONVILLE DOLPHINS | W 78-73 | 2-4 | K. Fleming 15 | K. Fleming 3 | J. Steele 6 |
| December 5, 2039 |  @ George Washington Colonials | L 71-90 | 2-5 | S. Poge 15 | K. Fleming 6 | D. Gelbard 5 |
| December 10, 2039 |  @ TCU Horned Frogs | W 77-75 OT | 3-5 | J. Steele 20 | K. Fleming 5 | D. Gelbard 11 |
| December 13, 2039 |  AKRON ZIPS | W 70-52 | 4-5 | J. Steele 16 | K. Fleming 6 | D. Gelbard 7 |
| December 16, 2039 |  DREXEL DRAGONS | L 77-82 OT | 4-6 | J. Steele 13 | K. Fleming 3 | R. Sullivan 9 |
| December 20, 2039 |  @ DePaul Blue Demons | L 51-65 | 4-7 | K. Fleming 16 | K. Fleming 5 | D. Gelbard 8 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ IU Indy Jaguars* | L 70-85 | 4-8 | J. Steele 15 | K. Fleming 3 | D. Gelbard 7 |
| January 4, 2040 |  @ Green Bay Phoenix* | L 73-85 | 4-9 | K. Fleming 16 | J. Steele 4 | D. Gelbard 7 |
| January 6, 2040 |  OAKLAND GOLDEN GRIZZLIES* | W 69-62 | 5-9 | S. Poge 11 | K. Fleming 4 | D. Gelbard 9 |
| January 11, 2040 |  @ Milwaukee Panthers* | L 74-78 | 5-10 | K. Fleming 15 | K. Fleming 4 | G. DeWolfe 6 |
| January 13, 2040 |  YOUNGSTOWN STATE PENGUINS* | W 77-67 | 6-10 | G. DeWolfe 17 | K. Fleming 4 | D. Gelbard 8 |
| January 16, 2040 |  PURDUE FORT WAYNE MASTODONS* | W 78-62 | 7-10 | J. Steele 16 | J. Watkins 4 | D. Gelbard 9 |
| January 23, 2040 | GREEN BAY PHOENIX* | W 65-45 | 8-10 | S. Poge 12 | K. Fleming 5 | D. Gelbard 10 |
| January 25, 2040 |  @ Detroit Mercy Titans* | L 55-67 | 8-11 | G. DeWolfe 13 | K. Fleming 6 | S. Poge 4 |
| January 27, 2040 | @ Oakland Golden Grizzlies* | L 62-75 | 8-12 | J. Steele 18 | K. Fleming 3 | D. Gelbard 8 |
| February 1, 2040 |  @ Northern Kentucky Norse* | L 60-74 | 8-13 | J. Steele 15 | K. Fleming 6 | J. Steele 8 |
| February 3, 2040 |  ROBERT MORRIS COLONIALS* | L 75-85 | 8-14 | D. Gelbard 16 | K. Fleming 9 | S. Poge 5 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ Robert Morris Colonials* | L 65-84 | 8-15 | K. Fleming 17 | K. Fleming 4 | R. Sullivan 5 |
| February 10, 2040 |  WRIGHT STATE RAIDERS* | W 90-86 OT | 9-15 | K. Fleming 24 | S. Poge 5 | G. DeWolfe 9 |
| February 15, 2040 | @ Purdue Fort Wayne Mastodons* | L 61-77 | 9-16 | R. Sullivan 18 | K. Fleming 5 | S. Poge 4 |
| February 17, 2040 | NORTHERN KENTUCKY NORSE* | W 89-65 | 10-16 | K. Fleming 14 | J. Watkins 7 | G. DeWolfe 6 |
| February 20, 2040 | MILWAUKEE PANTHERS* | W 80-75 | 11-16 | D. Gelbard 13 | J. Steele 5 | J. Steele 6 |
| February 22, 2040 | DETROIT MERCY TITANS* | W 80-54 | 12-16 | D. Gelbard 13 | K. Fleming 6 | G. DeWolfe 7 |
| February 27, 2040 | @ Youngstown State Penguins* | W 68-56 | 13-16 | G. DeWolfe 14 | K. Fleming 4 | S. Poge 7 |
| March 5, 2040 | NORTHERN KENTUCKY NORSE  Horizon Tournament | W 85-80 | 14-16 | K. Fleming 29 | K. Fleming 4 | D. Gelbard 8 |
| March 6, 2040 | @ Wright State Raiders Horizon Tournament | L 61-62 | 14-17 | K. Fleming 14 | D. Gelbard 4 | D. Gelbard 9 |
