| November 16, 2039 |  WEST VIRGINIA MOUNTAINEERS | W 81-71 | 1-0 | S. Baggett 19 | K. Marion 4 | R. Heideman 7 |
| November 18, 2039 |  NICHOLLS STATE COLONELS  Emerald Coast Classic | W 79-65 | 2-0 | S. Baggett 16 | M. Roy 7 | E. Formoselle 14 |
| November 19, 2039 |  PENN STATE NITTANY LIONS Emerald Coast Classic | W 73-66 | 3-0 | S. Baggett 15 | R. Heideman 7 | R. Heideman 8 |
| November 20, 2039 |  @ #5 Louisville Cardinals Emerald Coast Classic | W 72-47 | 4-0 | M. Roy 15 | M. Roy 4 | L. Van Dyke 7 |
| November 25, 2039 |  JAMES MADISON DUKES | L 73-86 | 4-1 | L. Van Dyke 19 | M. Roy 6 | R. Coffey 6 |
| November 27, 2039 |  STONEHILL SKYHAWKS | W 94-66 | 5-1 | R. Heideman 15 | R. Heideman 6 | E. Formoselle 6 |
| November 29, 2039 |  ARKANSAS PINE BLUFF GOLDEN LIONS | W 75-69 | 6-1 | L. Van Dyke 14 | R. Heideman 6 | E. Formoselle 13 |
| December 13, 2039 |  @ #2 North Carolina Tar Heels | L 63-79 | 6-2 | L. Van Dyke 16 | R. Heideman 5 | L. Van Dyke 9 |
| December 17, 2039 |  #10 TEXAS LONGHORNS | L 60-88 | 6-3 | M. Roy 13 | R. Heideman 2 | E. Formoselle 9 |
| December 20, 2039 |  OREGON DUCKS | W 95-71 | 7-3 | R. Heideman 16 | R. Heideman 7 | S. Baggett 6 |
| December 22, 2039 |  #18 TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS | W 72-67 | 8-3 | G. Lyle 16 | R. Heideman 7 | E. Formoselle 6 |
| December 26, 2039 |  PROVIDENCE FRIARS* | W 76-60 | 9-3 | L. Van Dyke 19 | R. Heideman 7 | K. Marion 6 |
| December 28, 2039 |  @ Seton Hall Pirates* | L 58-72 | 9-4 | S. Baggett 12 | R. Heideman 6 | E. Formoselle 9 |
| December 30, 2039 |  @ Xavier Musketeers* | L 76-77 | 9-5 | R. Heideman 16 | K. Marion 6 | K. Marion 7 |
| January 2, 2040 |  GEORGETOWN HOYAS* | L 63-71 | 9-6 | L. Van Dyke 14 | R. Heideman 4 | L. Van Dyke 7 |
| January 4, 2040 |  @ Creighton Blue Jays* | L 76-85 | 9-7 | L. Van Dyke 16 | R. Heideman 6 | E. Formoselle 8 |
| January 9, 2040 |  ST. JOHN'S RED STORM* | L 78-89 | 9-8 | R. Coffey 12 | R. Heideman 4 | E. Formoselle 7 |
| January 13, 2040 |  VILLANOVA WILDCATS* | L 73-87 | 9-9 | M. Roy 16 | R. Heideman 5 | E. Formoselle 8 |
| January 18, 2040 |  @ DePaul Blue Demons* | L 62-72 | 9-10 | S. Baggett 13 | M. Roy 5 | K. Marion 8 |
| January 20, 2040 |  @ Butler Bulldogs* | W 84-75 | 10-10 | S. Baggett 17 | R. Heideman 9 | E. Formoselle 11 |
| January 25, 2040 | @ St. John's Red Storm* | L 56-66 | 10-11 | E. Formoselle 13 | R. Heideman 4 | L. Van Dyke 10 |
| January 27, 2040 |  @ Marquette Golden Eagles* | L 61-89 | 10-12 | L. Van Dyke 14 | R. Heideman 4 | S. Baggett 5 |
| February 1, 2040 | CREIGHTON BLUE JAYS* | W 94-51 | 11-12 | S. Baggett 19 | R. Heideman 9 | L. Van Dyke 6 |
| February 3, 2040 | @ Villanova Wildcats* | L 61-70 | 11-13 | S. Baggett 14 | R. Heideman 3 | R. Coffey 10 |
| February 8, 2040 | BUTLER BULLDOGS* | W 55-41 | 12-13 | R. Coffey 10 | R. Heideman 3 | E. Formoselle 9 |
| February 10, 2040 | DEPAUL BLUE DEMONS* | W 72-62 | 13-13 | S. Baggett 14 | R. Heideman 6 | E. Formoselle 9 |
| February 17, 2040 | MARQUETTE GOLDEN EAGLES* | L 64-87 | 13-14 | L. Van Dyke 24 | R. Heideman 4 | E. Formoselle 7 |
| February 22, 2040 | @ #12 Georgetown Hoyas* | L 66-81 | 13-15 | C. Bruton 18 | M. Roy 4 | E. Formoselle 9 |
| February 24, 2040 | @ Providence Friars* | L 67-77 | 13-16 | S. Baggett 17 | R. Heideman 5 | E. Formoselle 11 |
| March 1, 2040 | #21 XAVIER MUSKETEERS* | W 88-82 | 14-16 | R. Heideman 17 | R. Heideman 9 | K. Marion 8 |
| March 3, 2040 | #22 SETON HALL PIRATES* | W 81-77 OT | 15-16 | G. Lyle 14 | M. Roy 4 | E. Formoselle 8 |
| March 9, 2040 | CREIGHTON BLUE JAYS  Big East Tournament | L 81-89 | 15-17 | S. Baggett 17 | R. Heideman 7 | E. Formoselle 7 |
