| November 14, 2037 | @ VMI Keydets | L 64-66 | 0-1 | T. Searcy 21 | T. Wilson 9 | V. Gilbert 6 |
| November 18, 2037 | @ Arkansas-Pine Bluff Golden Lions | L 58-61 | 0-2 | V. Gilbert 17 | T. Wilson 8 | C. Holmes 9 |
| November 23, 2037 | @ Duquesne Dukes | L 86-88 | 0-3 | V. Gilbert 20 | T. Wilson 6 | C. Holmes 7 |
| November 24, 2037 | @ Hofstra Pride | L 70-83 | 0-4 | D. Johnson 16 | T. Wilson 9 | V. Gilbert 6 |
| November 29, 2037 | @ Texas Tech Red Raiders | L 51-72 | 0-5 | T. Searcy 17 | T. Wilson 5 | D. Johnson 7 |
| December 2, 2037 | @ Morgan State Bears | W 85-83 OT | 1-5 | D. Johnson 19 | T. Searcy 6 | C. Holmes 10 |
| December 6, 2037 | @ Western Illinois Leathernecks | W 88-84 | 2-5 | T. Searcy 20 | R. Strohm 5 | C. Holmes 10 |
| December 13, 2037 | SACRED HEART PIONEERS | W 82-64 | 3-5 | G. Mann 21 | T. Wilson 6 | D. Johnson 7 |
| December 20, 2037 | NC-CENTRAL EAGLES | W 76-59 | 4-5 | C. Holmes 18 | T. Wilson 5 | C. Holmes 9 |
| December 23, 2037 | @ Long Island Sharks | L 62-75 | 4-6 | T. Searcy 13 | T. Wilson 5 | D. Johnson 7 |
| December 26, 2037 | MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD | L 63-77 | 4-7 | T. Searcy 19 | T. Wilson 5 | C. Holmes 9 |
| January 2, 2038 | CANISIUS GOLDEN GRIFFINS* | W 66-58 | 5-7 | V. Gilbert 14 | T. Wilson 4 | V. Gilbert 13 |
| January 6, 2038 | @ Saint Peters Peacocks* | L 64-66 | 5-8 | V. Gilbert 11 | T. Wilson 4 | D. Johnson 7 |
| January 11, 2038 | MARIST RED FOXES* | W 88-80 | 6-8 | T. Searcy 25 | T. Wilson 4 | D. Johnson 8 |
| January 13, 2038 | @ Iona Gaels* | W 65-60 | 7-8 | T. Wilson 12 | T. Wilson 6 | C. Holmes 9 |
| January 16, 2038 | @ Canisius Golden Griffins* | L 74-85 | 7-9 | V. Gilbert 18 | T. Wilson 2 | C. Holmes 7 |
| January 18, 2038 | MANHATTAN JASPERS* | W 74-51 | 8-9 | T. Searcy 16 | T. Wilson 9 | D. Johnson 8 |
| January 20, 2038 | SAINT PETERS PEACOCKS* | W 67-66 | 9-9 | D. Johnson 13 | T. Wilson 5 | C. Holmes 6 |
| January 23, 2038 | @ Rider Broncs* | W 80-69 | 10-9 | C. Holmes 18 | T. Wilson 7 | C. Holmes 9 |
| January 27, 2038 | NIAGARA PURPLE EAGLES* | W 84-65 | 11-9 | V. Gilbert 19 | T. Wilson 9 | D. Johnson 11 |
| February 1, 2038 | @ Mount St. Marys Mountaineers* | L 73-76 | 11-10 | T. Searcy 18 | T. Wilson 8 | V. Gilbert 5 |
| February 3, 2038 | @ Siena Saints* | W 80-60 | 12-10 | C. Holmes 17 | R. Strohm 5 | C. Holmes 8 |
| February 6, 2038 | @ Niagara Purple Eagles* | W 75-68 | 13-10 | T. Wilson 12 | T. Wilson 8 | D. Johnson 11 |
| February 10, 2038 | QUINNIPIAC BOBCATS* | L 64-86 | 13-11 | T. Searcy 13 | C. Holmes 5 | V. Gilbert 6 |
| February 13, 2038 | MOUNT ST. MARYS MOUNTAINEERS* | W 70-66 | 14-11 | V. Gilbert 14 | V. Gilbert 5 | V. Gilbert 12 |
| February 15, 2038 | @ Manhattan Jaspers* | W 76-73 | 15-11 | C. Holmes 21 | T. Wilson 7 | D. Johnson 8 |
| February 20, 2038 | @ Marist Red Foxes* | W 89-80 OT | 16-11 | T. Searcy 20 | R. Strohm 4 | C. Holmes 10 |
| February 22, 2038 | RIDER BRONCS* | W 69-62 | 17-11 | T. Wilson 14 | T. Wilson 4 | V. Gilbert 6 |
| March 1, 2038 | SIENA SAINTS* | W 81-60 | 18-11 | V. Gilbert 20 | T. Wilson 8 | D. Johnson 6 |
| March 6, 2038 | SIENA SAINTS MAAC Tournament | W 80-69 | 19-11 | T. Wilson 19 | T. Wilson 6 | D. Johnson 11 |
| March 7, 2038 | MOUNT ST. MARYS MOUNTAINEERS MAAC Tournament | W 79-66 | 20-11 | D. Johnson 18 | G. Mann 5 | C. Holmes 8 |
| March 8, 2038 | @ Marist Red Foxes MAAC Tournament | W 68-66 | 21-11 | C. Holmes 17 | T. Wilson 7 | C. Holmes 10 |
| March 14, 2038 | ARMY BLACK KNIGHTS NCAA Tournament | L 78-86 | 21-12 | V. Gilbert 22 | T. Wilson 4 | D. Johnson 6 |
