| November 14, 2039 |  @ #1 Texas Longhorns  NIT Season Tip-Off | L 61-70 | 0-1 | D. Hedde 14 | D. Greenberg 5 | D. Hedde 10 |
| November 29, 2039 |  @ #7 Louisville Cardinals | L 71-91 | 0-2 | D. Hedde 19 | D. Greenberg 5 | C. Dye 8 |
| December 3, 2039 |  PORTLAND STATE VIKINGS | W 86-54 | 1-2 | D. Hedde 14 | P. Forrest 5 | D. Hedde 9 |
| December 7, 2039 |  @ Eastern Washington Eagles | L 72-87 | 1-3 | D. Hedde 12 | D. Herrion 5 | C. Dye 6 |
| December 10, 2039 |  JACKSONVILLE DOLPHINS | W 83-68 | 2-3 | D. Greenberg 29 | P. Forrest 4 | B. Potts 6 |
| December 13, 2039 |  @ Youngstown State Penguins | W 74-61 | 3-3 | A. Vining 14 | P. Forrest 4 | C. Dye 9 |
| December 17, 2039 |  @ Lipscomb Bisons | W 79-69 | 4-3 | A. Vining 16 | D. Greenberg 3 | D. Hedde 8 |
| December 21, 2039 |  @ Florida Gulf Coast Eagles | W 85-69 | 5-3 | D. Hedde 25 | D. Herrion 8 | D. Hedde 6 |
| December 24, 2039 |  NORTH FLORIDA OSPREY | W 80-71 | 6-3 | D. Greenberg 16 | D. Greenberg 6 | A. Vining 9 |
| December 26, 2039 |  NORTHERN ILLINOIS HUSKIES* | W 92-86 | 7-3 | D. Hedde 30 | D. Herrion 6 | D. Hedde 8 |
| December 29, 2039 |  OHIO BOBCATS* | W 74-60 | 8-3 | D. Hedde 12 | P. Forrest 5 | D. Herrion 9 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ Eastern Michigan Eagles* | L 59-70 | 8-4 | A. Vining 23 | D. Greenberg 7 | D. Hedde 6 |
| January 5, 2040 |  @ Western Michigan Broncos* | W 80-79 | 9-4 | D. Hedde 18 | A. Vining 3 | B. Potts 9 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Central Michigan Chippewas* | L 78-92 | 9-5 | C. Dye 18 | P. Buchanan 4 | D. Herrion 8 |
| January 12, 2040 |  BOWLING GREEN FALCONS* | L 69-75 | 9-6 | A. Vining 25 | C. Dye 3 | B. Potts 6 |
| January 16, 2040 |  AKRON ZIPS* | L 67-69 | 9-7 | D. Greenberg 19 | D. Greenberg 7 | C. Dye 13 |
| January 19, 2040 |  @ Miami (OH) Red Hawks* | W 80-75 | 10-7 | D. Hedde 25 | D. Greenberg 7 | D. Hedde 7 |
| January 23, 2040 |  @ Toledo Rockets* | W 74-67 | 11-7 | D. Greenberg 37 | D. Herrion 6 | D. Herrion 11 |
| January 26, 2040 |  @ Ball State Cardinals* | W 105-103 OT | 12-7 | D. Greenberg 24 | D. Greenberg 5 | D. Herrion 8 |
| January 30, 2040 | MIAMI (OH) RED HAWKS* | L 73-83 | 12-8 | B. Potts 15 | A. Vining 5 | D. Herrion 6 |
| February 2, 2040 | TOLEDO ROCKETS* | W 80-56 | 13-8 | D. Greenberg 15 | D. Greenberg 4 | D. Herrion 8 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ Bowling Green Falcons* | W 80-79 | 14-8 | A. Vining 31 | D. Greenberg 8 | C. Dye 7 |
| February 9, 2040 | @ #24 Akron Zips* | L 101-106 | 14-9 | D. Greenberg 28 | D. Greenberg 6 | D. Hedde 7 |
| February 13, 2040 | EASTERN MICHIGAN EAGLES* | W 69-51 | 15-9 | D. Greenberg 28 | D. Herrion 6 | C. Dye 8 |
| February 16, 2040 | WESTERN MICHIGAN BRONCOS* | L 71-80 | 15-10 | A. Vining 15 | P. Forrest 5 | C. Dye 8 |
| February 20, 2040 | @ Northern Illinois Huskies* | L 82-87 | 15-11 | A. Vining 20 | D. Greenberg 11 | C. Dye 9 |
| February 23, 2040 | @ Ohio Bobcats* | L 55-82 | 15-12 | D. Hedde 17 | D. Greenberg 6 | D. Herrion 4 |
| February 27, 2040 | BALL STATE CARDINALS* | W 74-65 | 16-12 | A. Vining 20 | D. Greenberg 3 | C. Dye 11 |
| March 2, 2040 |  BUFFALO BULLS* | W 81-73 | 17-12 | D. Greenberg 24 | D. Herrion 7 | D. Herrion 7 |
| March 8, 2040 | NORTHERN ILLINOIS HUSKIES  MAC Tournament | W 89-81 | 18-12 | D. Hedde 17 | D. Greenberg 5 | B. Potts 7 |
| March 9, 2040 | @ #24 Akron Zips MAC Tournament | L 79-88 | 18-13 | A. Vining 19 | A. Vining 6 | D. Herrion 10 |
