| November 25, 2039 |  @ Iowa State Cyclones  ESPN Events Invitational | L 75-84 | 0-1 | D. Caldwell 19 | P. Waldman 9 | L. Celuck 7 |
| November 28, 2039 |  @ Ole Miss Rebels | L 53-80 | 0-2 | D. Caldwell 10 | L. Lepore 4 | B. Gates 9 |
| December 1, 2039 |  MURRAY STATE RACERS | L 71-74 | 0-3 | L. Lepore 13 | P. Waldman 3 | L. Lepore 7 |
| December 7, 2039 |  NORTHERN COLORADO BEARS | W 95-69 | 1-3 | P. Waldman 21 | P. Waldman 6 | B. Poleska 5 |
| December 9, 2039 |  @ Stanford Cardinal | L 62-77 | 1-4 | P. Waldman 13 | P. Waldman 4 | D. Caldwell 11 |
| December 13, 2039 |  @ Northern Kentucky Norse | W 76-60 | 2-4 | L. Celuck 21 | P. Waldman 7 | M. Holmes 8 |
| December 17, 2039 |  NAVY MIDSHIPMEN | W 76-71 OT | 3-4 | L. Celuck 17 | P. Waldman 4 | D. Caldwell 8 |
| December 19, 2039 |  @ Winthrop Eagles | L 66-92 | 3-5 | J. Cassel 13 | P. Waldman 6 | L. Celuck 5 |
| December 22, 2039 |  HIGH POINT PANTHERS | W 82-66 | 4-5 | O. Grizzard 20 | P. Waldman 9 | L. Celuck 11 |
| December 26, 2039 |  CENTRAL MICHIGAN CHIPPEWAS* | W 90-75 | 5-5 | P. Waldman 19 | P. Waldman 6 | D. Caldwell 9 |
| December 29, 2039 |  BUFFALO BULLS* | W 85-69 | 6-5 | P. Waldman 26 | P. Waldman 9 | D. Caldwell 7 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ Bowling Green Falcons* | W 78-65 | 7-5 | P. Waldman 17 | P. Waldman 5 | M. Holmes 7 |
| January 5, 2040 |  @ Akron Zips* | L 71-78 | 7-6 | J. Cassel 14 | P. Waldman 5 | L. Celuck 8 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Eastern Michigan Eagles* | W 69-56 | 8-6 | L. Lepore 12 | P. Waldman 5 | L. Celuck 6 |
| January 12, 2040 |  NORTHERN ILLINOIS HUSKIES* | W 76-59 | 9-6 | P. Waldman 17 | P. Waldman 6 | L. Celuck 7 |
| January 16, 2040 |  @ Ohio Bobcats* | L 63-70 | 9-7 | L. Celuck 13 | P. Waldman 6 | L. Celuck 6 |
| January 19, 2040 |  KENT STATE GOLDEN FLASHES* | L 75-80 | 9-8 | O. Grizzard 21 | P. Waldman 5 | D. Caldwell 8 |
| January 23, 2040 |  BALL STATE CARDINALS* | W 89-66 | 10-8 | D. Caldwell 19 | P. Waldman 8 | B. Gates 7 |
| January 26, 2040 | OHIO BOBCATS* | W 67-59 | 11-8 | P. Waldman 12 | P. Waldman 7 | L. Celuck 8 |
| January 30, 2040 | @ Kent State Golden Flashes* | W 83-73 | 12-8 | L. Lepore 15 | P. Waldman 5 | O. Grizzard 8 |
| February 2, 2040 | @ Ball State Cardinals* | L 80-86 OT | 12-9 | L. Celuck 18 | P. Waldman 4 | L. Celuck 12 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ Northern Illinois Huskies* | L 71-78 | 12-10 | P. Waldman 16 | P. Waldman 6 | D. Caldwell 5 |
| February 9, 2040 |  @ Toledo Rockets* | L 63-79 | 12-11 | P. Waldman 17 | P. Waldman 5 | B. Gates 7 |
| February 13, 2040 | BOWLING GREEN FALCONS* | W 75-60 | 13-11 | J. Cassel 15 | L. Celuck 4 | M. Holmes 7 |
| February 16, 2040 | #24 AKRON ZIPS* | W 72-59 | 14-11 | L. Lepore 18 | P. Waldman 5 | L. Celuck 10 |
| February 20, 2040 | @ Central Michigan Chippewas* | W 69-62 | 15-11 | J. Cassel 16 | P. Waldman 4 | L. Celuck 7 |
| February 23, 2040 | TOLEDO ROCKETS* | W 62-59 | 16-11 | J. Cassel 14 | J. Cassel 5 | L. Celuck 7 |
| February 27, 2040 | @ Buffalo Bulls* | L 70-87 | 16-12 | P. Waldman 14 | P. Waldman 8 | L. Celuck 8 |
| March 2, 2040 |  WESTERN MICHIGAN BRONCOS* | L 71-77 | 16-13 | P. Waldman 15 | L. Lepore 5 | L. Lepore 9 |
| March 8, 2040 | BOWLING GREEN FALCONS  MAC Tournament | L 61-80 | 16-14 | L. Celuck 12 | P. Waldman 4 | L. Celuck 9 |
