| November 15, 2039 |  TOWSON TIGERS | W 82-73 | 1-0 | D. Russell 20 | D. Russell 4 | D. Self 8 |
| November 18, 2039 |  ORAL ROBERTS GOLDEN EAGLES | L 69-84 | 1-1 | C. Dawson 17 | R. Wimbley 4 | C. Dawson 9 |
| November 23, 2039 |  NORTHERN COLORADO BEARS | W 75-58 | 2-1 | D. Hernandez 17 | R. Wimbley 5 | L. Shearer 10 |
| November 25, 2039 |  HAMPTON PIRATES | W 65-56 | 3-1 | D. Hernandez 19 | D. Self 3 | L. Shearer 10 |
| November 30, 2039 |  EASTERN WASHINGTON EAGLES | L 62-68 | 3-2 | D. Russell 13 | D. Hernandez 4 | D. Self 6 |
| December 1, 2039 |  NEW HAMPSHIRE WILDCATS | L 68-86 | 3-3 | D. Hernandez 15 | R. Wimbley 4 | R. Wimbley 5 |
| December 7, 2039 |  @ Howard Bison | L 81-91 OT | 3-4 | D. Hernandez 20 | R. Wimbley 6 | D. Wade 8 |
| December 10, 2039 |  FAIRFIELD STAGS | L 97-101 OT | 3-5 | R. Wimbley 20 | D. Hernandez 4 | D. Ward 7 |
| December 13, 2039 |  @ UMass Lowell River Hawks | W 80-75 | 4-5 | D. Russell 20 | R. Wimbley 6 | D. Wade 8 |
| December 16, 2039 |  @ Air Force Falcons | L 54-93 | 4-6 | D. Russell 15 | R. Wimbley 3 | L. Shearer 6 |
| December 21, 2039 |  MOUNT ST. MARY'S MOUNTAINEERS | W 87-70 | 5-6 | D. Hernandez 17 | R. Wimbley 8 | D. Wilkins 7 |
| December 22, 2039 |  CALIFORNIA BAPTIST LANCERS | W 84-80 | 6-6 | D. Ward 18 | R. Wimbley 3 | D. Wade 6 |
| December 26, 2039 |  @ Campbell Camels | L 49-60 | 6-7 | D. Ward 12 | D. Hernandez 4 | L. Shearer 11 |
| January 4, 2040 |  @ Wagner Seahawks* | L 64-70 | 6-8 | D. Hernandez 14 | D. Russell 5 | C. Dawson 7 |
| January 7, 2040 |  CENTRAL CONNECTICUT BLUE DEVILS* | W 80-70 | 7-8 | R. Wimbley 16 | R. Wimbley 5 | C. Dawson 6 |
| January 11, 2040 |  @ Saint Francis (PA) Red Flash* | W 80-69 | 8-8 | D. Wade 22 | R. Wimbley 5 | L. Shearer 9 |
| January 14, 2040 |  SACRED HEART PIONEERS* | W 66-63 | 9-8 | D. Hernandez 14 | D. Russell 3 | C. Dawson 7 |
| January 18, 2040 |  @ St. Francis (NY) Terriers* | L 72-84 | 9-9 | C. Dawson 17 | D. Self 4 | C. Dawson 6 |
| January 21, 2040 |  LIU SHARKS* | W 84-79 OT | 10-9 | D. Wade 21 | D. Hernandez 8 | C. Dawson 7 |
| January 28, 2040 |  @ FDU Knights* | L 56-66 | 10-10 | D. Wade 12 | D. Russell 4 | L. Shearer 12 |
| February 1, 2040 |  STONEHILL SKYHAWKS* | W 83-77 | 11-10 | C. Dawson 22 | D. Wade 6 | C. Dawson 10 |
| February 4, 2040 | WAGNER SEAHAWKS* | W 69-46 | 12-10 | D. Hernandez 17 | D. Russell 6 | D. Wade 9 |
| February 8, 2040 | @ Central Connecticut Blue Devils* | L 70-92 | 12-11 | D. Hernandez 21 | R. Wimbley 6 | D. Ward 5 |
| February 11, 2040 | SAINT FRANCIS (PA) RED FLASH* | W 79-69 | 13-11 | D. Hernandez 27 | R. Wimbley 4 | D. Self 7 |
| February 15, 2040 | @ Sacred Heart Pioneers* | L 67-78 | 13-12 | D. Hernandez 22 | R. Wimbley 8 | D. Hernandez 5 |
| February 18, 2040 | ST. FRANCIS (NY) TERRIERS* | W 71-60 | 14-12 | D. Wade 19 | D. Self 4 | C. Dawson 9 |
| February 22, 2040 | @ LIU Sharks* | W 65-55 | 15-12 | R. Wimbley 19 | D. Russell 4 | L. Shearer 5 |
| March 1, 2040 | FDU KNIGHTS* | L 74-76 | 15-13 | D. Hernandez 18 | D. Wade 4 | C. Dawson 11 |
| March 4, 2040 | @ Stonehill Skyhawks* | L 63-77 | 15-14 | D. Ward 16 | D. Russell 4 | D. Self 8 |
| March 6, 2040 | SACRED HEART PIONEERS  Northeast Tournament | W 76-75 | 16-14 | D. Wade 15 | R. Wimbley 9 | C. Dawson 9 |
| March 7, 2040 | @ Stonehill Skyhawks Northeast Tournament | W 103-95 OT | 17-14 | D. Russell 24 | R. Wimbley 6 | C. Dawson 9 |
| March 8, 2040 | SAINT FRANCIS (PA) RED FLASH Northeast Tournament | L 67-74 | 17-15 | D. Russell 14 | R. Wimbley 6 | R. Wimbley 4 |
