| November 14, 2039 |  @ Fordham Rams | L 55-72 | 0-1 | E. Castillo 14 | T. Leach 3 | E. George 9 |
| November 17, 2039 |  @ La Salle Explorers | L 72-93 | 0-2 | E. Castillo 15 | R. Holland 8 | E. Castillo 7 |
| November 21, 2039 |  @ Loyola Maryland Greyhounds | L 64-78 | 0-3 | E. Castillo 20 | R. Holland 7 | R. Holland 5 |
| November 24, 2039 |  @ San Jose State Spartans | W 86-69 | 1-3 | E. George 16 | R. Holland 4 | D. Gilbert 8 |
| November 28, 2039 |  @ Denver Pioneers | L 71-78 | 1-4 | R. Holland 19 | R. Holland 4 | E. George 8 |
| December 5, 2039 |  EASTERN MICHIGAN EAGLES | L 52-70 | 1-5 | R. Holland 13 | A. Kirk 5 | E. George 5 |
| December 8, 2039 |  @ Saint Louis Billikens | W 72-63 | 2-5 | E. Castillo 17 | R. Holland 10 | E. Castillo 7 |
| December 13, 2039 |  CENTRAL MICHIGAN CHIPPEWAS | W 88-80 | 3-5 | R. Holland 17 | T. Leach 4 | E. George 6 |
| December 20, 2039 |  @ Rutgers Scarlet Knights | L 61-74 | 3-6 | T. Leach 15 | E. George 4 | E. Castillo 5 |
| December 22, 2039 |  @ San Francisco Dons | L 74-81 | 3-7 | R. Holland 17 | R. Holland 6 | E. George 9 |
| December 26, 2039 |  @ Utah Utes | L 63-80 | 3-8 | R. Holland 18 | R. Holland 3 | E. George 9 |
| January 4, 2040 |  @ Purdue Fort Wayne Mastodons* | L 50-67 | 3-9 | T. Leach 11 | T. Leach 4 | R. Holland 5 |
| January 6, 2040 |  @ Cleveland State Vikings* | L 62-69 | 3-10 | R. Holland 20 | R. Holland 2 | T. Leach 7 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Youngstown State Penguins* | L 67-75 | 3-11 | E. George 14 | T. Leach 6 | E. George 10 |
| January 11, 2040 |  @ Robert Morris Colonials* | L 63-82 | 3-12 | E. Castillo 17 | R. Holland 6 | D. Gilbert 9 |
| January 13, 2040 |  NORTHERN KENTUCKY NORSE* | W 79-61 | 4-12 | R. Holland 14 | R. Holland 5 | E. George 12 |
| January 18, 2040 | PURDUE FORT WAYNE MASTODONS* | W 81-68 | 5-12 | T. Leach 20 | R. Holland 3 | E. Castillo 7 |
| January 20, 2040 |  DETROIT MERCY TITANS* | L 60-72 | 5-13 | T. Leach 16 | R. Holland 5 | T. Leach 5 |
| January 25, 2040 |  GREEN BAY PHOENIX* | W 78-60 | 6-13 | E. Castillo 19 | R. Holland 7 | D. Gilbert 6 |
| January 27, 2040 | CLEVELAND STATE VIKINGS* | W 75-62 | 7-13 | E. George 19 | R. Holland 5 | D. Gilbert 4 |
| January 30, 2040 |  @ Wright State Raiders* | W 88-82 | 8-13 | R. Holland 19 | R. Holland 3 | T. Leach 5 |
| February 3, 2040 |  MILWAUKEE PANTHERS* | W 59-46 | 9-13 | T. Leach 16 | R. Holland 2 | E. George 13 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ Green Bay Phoenix* | L 73-83 OT | 9-14 | T. Leach 17 | R. Holland 6 | D. Gilbert 7 |
| February 8, 2040 |  IU INDY JAGUARS* | W 69-54 | 10-14 | T. Leach 17 | E. Castillo 4 | E. George 12 |
| February 15, 2040 | @ Northern Kentucky Norse* | L 47-76 | 10-15 | T. Leach 9 | R. Holland 4 | E. George 7 |
| February 17, 2040 | @ Detroit Mercy Titans* | L 45-58 | 10-16 | R. Holland 12 | R. Holland 5 | E. George 10 |
| February 20, 2040 | YOUNGSTOWN STATE PENGUINS* | W 74-59 | 11-16 | R. Holland 23 | T. Leach 7 | R. Holland 6 |
| February 22, 2040 | WRIGHT STATE RAIDERS* | L 50-64 | 11-17 | E. Castillo 12 | A. Kirk 5 | E. George 8 |
| March 1, 2040 | @ Milwaukee Panthers* | L 62-87 | 11-18 | E. George 11 | R. Holland 4 | E. George 8 |
| March 5, 2040 | YOUNGSTOWN STATE PENGUINS  Horizon Tournament | W 85-82 | 12-18 | T. Leach 15 | R. Holland 6 | E. Castillo 5 |
| March 6, 2040 | @ Robert Morris Colonials Horizon Tournament | L 74-90 | 12-19 | T. Leach 21 | R. Holland 7 | E. Castillo 8 |
