| November 13, 2039 |  @ Harvard Crimson | L 78-92 | 0-1 | K. Crenshaw 27 | D. Whitman 4 | C. Small 8 |
| November 16, 2039 |  UNC GREENSBORO SPARTANS | L 55-67 | 0-2 | D. Whitman 24 | C. Tinsley 4 | C. Small 9 |
| November 17, 2039 |  RADFORD HIGHLANDERS | W 76-69 OT | 1-2 | D. Whitman 13 | C. Tinsley 7 | D. Whitman 5 |
| November 21, 2039 |  SOUTHERN UTAH THUNDERBIRDS | W 76-67 | 2-2 | C. Small 15 | D. Whitman 8 | J. Tobias 7 |
| November 24, 2039 |  @ Auburn Tigers | L 65-80 | 2-3 | D. Whitman 16 | K. Crenshaw 4 | C. Tinsley 4 |
| November 28, 2039 |  GRAMBLING TIGERS | L 56-69 | 2-4 | C. Tinsley 12 | C. Tinsley 4 | B. Dunleavy 8 |
| December 2, 2039 |  @ UNLV Runnin' Rebels | L 51-68 | 2-5 | J. Tobias 12 | C. Tinsley 4 | D. Whitman 7 |
| December 7, 2039 |  @ North Alabama Lions | L 60-74 | 2-6 | C. Small 15 | C. Tinsley 7 | C. Small 7 |
| December 10, 2039 |  @ Arkansas Pine Bluff Golden Lions | L 55-79 | 2-7 | D. Whitman 16 | D. Whitman 6 | C. Small 7 |
| December 13, 2039 |  @ NJIT Highlanders | L 68-89 | 2-8 | K. Crenshaw 15 | D. Whitman 3 | J. Tobias 9 |
| December 17, 2039 |  @ Cincinnati Bearcats | L 71-81 | 2-9 | B. Dunleavy 15 | D. Whitman 4 | J. Tobias 6 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ Canisius Golden Griffins* | L 67-75 | 2-10 | C. Tinsley 14 | G. Snyder 3 | J. Tobias 6 |
| January 6, 2040 |  @ Marist Red Foxes* | L 59-81 | 2-11 | C. Tinsley 15 | K. Crenshaw 4 | J. Tobias 7 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Manhattan Jaspers* | L 53-60 | 2-12 | B. Dunleavy 14 | J. Tobias 3 | B. Dunleavy 8 |
| January 11, 2040 |  SIENA SAINTS* | W 68-53 | 3-12 | K. Crenshaw 15 | C. Tinsley 6 | B. Dunleavy 5 |
| January 16, 2040 | CANISIUS GOLDEN GRIFFINS* | W 81-68 | 4-12 | K. Crenshaw 19 | D. Riviere 5 | D. Whitman 5 |
| January 20, 2040 |  @ Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers* | L 73-76 | 4-13 | C. Tinsley 19 | B. Dunleavy 4 | B. Dunleavy 7 |
| January 25, 2040 |  RIDER BRONCS* | W 54-50 | 5-13 | C. Tinsley 11 | D. Whitman 3 | C. Tinsley 9 |
| January 27, 2040 |  QUINNIPIAC BOBCATS* | L 74-81 | 5-14 | B. Dunleavy 15 | C. Tinsley 6 | A. Gates 6 |
| January 30, 2040 |  FAIRFIELD STAGS* | W 80-69 | 6-14 | D. Whitman 16 | K. Crenshaw 5 | B. Dunleavy 7 |
| February 6, 2040 |  NIAGARA PURPLE EAGLES* | W 76-70 | 7-14 | K. Crenshaw 15 | D. Whitman 5 | B. Dunleavy 8 |
| February 8, 2040 |  IONA GAELS* | W 63-58 | 8-14 | K. Crenshaw 15 | B. Dunleavy 4 | B. Dunleavy 6 |
| February 10, 2040 | @ Quinnipiac Bobcats* | L 73-101 | 8-15 | C. Tinsley 18 | K. Crenshaw 5 | B. Dunleavy 5 |
| February 13, 2040 | @ Siena Saints* | L 73-92 | 8-16 | C. Small 19 | C. Tinsley 7 | B. Dunleavy 7 |
| February 15, 2040 | @ Fairfield Stags* | W 64-50 | 9-16 | K. Crenshaw 17 | C. Tinsley 5 | B. Dunleavy 5 |
| February 17, 2040 | MOUNT ST. MARY'S MOUNTAINEERS* | W 77-67 | 10-16 | D. Whitman 17 | C. Tinsley 7 | J. Tobias 8 |
| February 22, 2040 | @ Rider Broncs* | L 69-78 | 10-17 | K. Crenshaw 30 | D. Whitman 5 | B. Dunleavy 7 |
| February 27, 2040 | MANHATTAN JASPERS* | W 78-70 | 11-17 | J. Tobias 18 | C. Tinsley 5 | J. Tobias 8 |
| March 1, 2040 | @ Niagara Purple Eagles* | W 77-69 | 12-17 | D. Whitman 19 | C. Tinsley 7 | K. Campbell 6 |
| March 6, 2040 | SIENA SAINTS  MAAC Tournament | W 71-68 | 13-17 | D. Whitman 12 | C. Tinsley 4 | C. Small 8 |
| March 7, 2040 | @ Niagara Purple Eagles MAAC Tournament | W 78-60 | 14-17 | C. Tinsley 17 | C. Tinsley 7 | B. Dunleavy 12 |
| March 8, 2040 | MARIST RED FOXES MAAC Tournament | W 64-63 OT | 15-17 | C. Small 11 | D. Whitman 7 | J. Tobias 8 |
