| November 15, 2039 |  @ #25 Miami (FL) Hurricanes | L 67-79 | 0-1 | R. Blankenship 12 | K. Bellamy 3 | J. Underwood 13 |
| November 19, 2039 |  @ Howard Bison | W 85-71 | 1-1 | K. Bellamy 17 | K. Bellamy 7 | J. Stoudamire 7 |
| November 23, 2039 |  @ Liberty Flames | L 54-84 | 1-2 | T. Boone 10 | K. Bellamy 7 | T. McFall 5 |
| November 26, 2039 |  @ Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers | L 56-63 | 1-3 | T. McFall 12 | K. Bellamy 6 | J. Underwood 6 |
| November 28, 2039 |  @ Longwood Lancers | W 52-50 | 2-3 | K. Bellamy 17 | K. Bellamy 3 | J. Underwood 8 |
| December 7, 2039 |  @ Texas Tech Red Raiders | L 55-66 | 2-4 | J. Coleman 11 | K. Bellamy 7 | J. Stoudamire 8 |
| December 10, 2039 |  CENTRAL CONNECTICUT BLUE DEVILS | L 58-72 | 2-5 | T. McFall 16 | K. Bellamy 4 | J. Stoudamire 16 |
| December 13, 2039 |  CHATTANOOGA MOCS | W 77-65 | 3-5 | J. Stoudamire 23 | W. Hughes 4 | J. Underwood 10 |
| December 20, 2039 |  @ Air Force Falcons | L 55-75 | 3-6 | T. McFall 12 | J. Stoudamire 2 | J. Underwood 8 |
| December 22, 2039 |  UT RIO GRANDE VALLEY VAQUEROS | W 66-58 | 4-6 | W. Hughes 21 | K. Bellamy 6 | J. Underwood 12 |
| December 28, 2039 |  CANISIUS GOLDEN GRIFFINS | W 72-54 | 5-6 | K. Bellamy 19 | K. Bellamy 5 | J. Underwood 15 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ Eastern Illinois Panthers* | L 65-82 | 5-7 | J. Stoudamire 19 | T. McFall 3 | J. Underwood 8 |
| January 5, 2040 |  SE MISSOURI STATE REDHAWKS* | W 73-59 | 6-7 | J. Stoudamire 19 | K. Bellamy 6 | J. Underwood 10 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Southern Indiana Screaming Eagles* | W 66-57 | 7-7 | T. McFall 14 | K. Bellamy 6 | J. Underwood 6 |
| January 12, 2040 |  TENNESSEE STATE TIGERS* | L 75-89 | 7-8 | W. Hughes 20 | W. Hughes 6 | J. Underwood 11 |
| January 16, 2040 |  @ UT Martin Skyhawks* | L 74-84 OT | 7-9 | T. McFall 25 | W. Hughes 3 | J. Stoudamire 10 |
| January 19, 2040 |  MOREHEAD STATE EAGLES* | L 70-78 | 7-10 | T. McFall 13 | K. Bellamy 8 | T. McFall 8 |
| January 23, 2040 |  @ Lindenwood Lions* | W 83-75 | 8-10 | K. Bellamy 20 | W. Hughes 4 | J. Stoudamire 7 |
| January 26, 2040 |  LITTLE ROCK TROJANS* | W 88-75 | 9-10 | T. McFall 17 | K. Bellamy 5 | J. Underwood 10 |
| January 30, 2040 |  @ SIU Edwardsville Cougars* | L 75-90 | 9-11 | T. McFall 16 | J. Stoudamire 3 | J. Stoudamire 9 |
| February 2, 2040 | EASTERN ILLINOIS PANTHERS* | W 68-58 | 10-11 | J. Stoudamire 19 | K. Bellamy 4 | W. Hughes 7 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ SE Missouri State Redhawks* | W 68-60 | 11-11 | T. McFall 18 | K. Bellamy 4 | J. Underwood 13 |
| February 9, 2040 | SOUTHERN INDIANA SCREAMING EAGLES* | W 75-55 | 12-11 | J. Stoudamire 16 | K. Bellamy 6 | J. Underwood 8 |
| February 13, 2040 | @ Tennessee State Tigers* | L 57-68 | 12-12 | J. Stoudamire 11 | K. Bellamy 4 | J. Stoudamire 12 |
| February 16, 2040 | UT MARTIN SKYHAWKS* | L 76-87 | 12-13 | T. McFall 15 | W. Hughes 3 | W. Hughes 6 |
| February 20, 2040 | @ Morehead State Eagles* | L 52-69 | 12-14 | T. McFall 15 | K. Bellamy 3 | J. Underwood 7 |
| February 23, 2040 | LINDENWOOD LIONS* | W 77-64 | 13-14 | T. McFall 19 | K. Bellamy 4 | J. Underwood 15 |
| February 27, 2040 | @ Little Rock Trojans* | W 69-51 | 14-14 | T. McFall 18 | J. Stoudamire 6 | J. Underwood 8 |
| March 2, 2040 | SIU EDWARDSVILLE COUGARS* | W 75-69 | 15-14 | T. McFall 19 | K. Bellamy 8 | J. Stoudamire 10 |
| March 5, 2040 | LINDENWOOD LIONS  OVC Tournament | W 73-72 | 16-14 | T. McFall 17 | W. Hughes 5 | J. Stoudamire 8 |
| March 6, 2040 | @ UT Martin Skyhawks OVC Tournament | L 60-76 | 16-15 | T. McFall 18 | J. Coleman 4 | J. Underwood 11 |
