| November 15, 2039 |  HOFSTRA PRIDE | W 83-64 | 1-0 | C. Day 18 | K. Hollins 6 | L. McCauley 6 |
| November 17, 2039 |  @ Western Carolina Catamounts | W 79-67 | 2-0 | K. Hollins 19 | J. Farnsworth 5 | C. Day 9 |
| November 21, 2039 |  @ Oral Roberts Golden Eagles | W 81-63 | 3-0 | C. Day 29 | M. Lyles 4 | L. McCauley 9 |
| November 26, 2039 |  @ Gonzaga Bulldogs | L 67-88 | 3-1 | H. Murphy 13 | E. Carstensen 7 | L. McCauley 4 |
| November 29, 2039 |  @ Pennsylvania Quakers | L 64-76 | 3-2 | J. Farnsworth 18 | K. Hollins 4 | L. McCauley 5 |
| December 5, 2039 |  ARMY BLACK KNIGHTS | L 65-85 | 3-3 | C. Day 10 | K. Hollins 6 | L. Rucker 6 |
| December 8, 2039 |  @ Arkansas Razorbacks | W 56-45 | 4-3 | J. Farnsworth 14 | K. Hollins 6 | E. Carstensen 9 |
| December 13, 2039 |  CHICAGO STATE COUGARS | W 85-70 | 5-3 | K. Hollins 18 | K. Hollins 5 | E. Carstensen 10 |
| December 19, 2039 |  GRAMBLING TIGERS | L 56-74 | 5-4 | C. Day 13 | K. Hollins 5 | C. Day 7 |
| December 26, 2039 |  NORTHERN IOWA PANTHERS* | W 87-73 | 6-4 | E. Carstensen 17 | K. Hollins 3 | L. McCauley 6 |
| December 29, 2039 |  INDIANA STATE SYCAMORES* | W 69-63 | 7-4 | J. Farnsworth 19 | K. Hollins 7 | L. McCauley 12 |
| January 2, 2040 |  @ Missouri State Bears* | L 86-90 OT | 7-5 | C. Day 25 | L. McCauley 4 | C. Day 9 |
| January 5, 2040 |  @ Illinois State Redbirds* | W 82-71 | 8-5 | C. Day 17 | J. Farnsworth 4 | E. Carstensen 7 |
| January 9, 2040 |  @ Bradley Braves* | L 61-70 | 8-6 | J. Farnsworth 12 | K. Hollins 7 | J. Farnsworth 5 |
| January 12, 2040 |  SOUTHERN ILLINOIS SALUKIS* | W 79-68 | 9-6 | K. Hollins 15 | K. Hollins 6 | E. Carstensen 10 |
| January 16, 2040 |  @ Murray State Racers* | L 48-92 | 9-7 | C. Day 9 | J. Farnsworth 3 | L. McCauley 7 |
| January 19, 2040 |  BELMONT BRUINS* | W 69-66 | 10-7 | K. Hollins 18 | J. Farnsworth 3 | E. Carstensen 7 |
| January 23, 2040 |  DRAKE BULLDOGS* | L 62-69 | 10-8 | C. Day 16 | J. Farnsworth 5 | E. Carstensen 6 |
| January 26, 2040 | MURRAY STATE RACERS* | L 74-89 | 10-9 | J. Farnsworth 16 | M. Lyles 4 | E. Carstensen 6 |
| January 30, 2040 | @ Belmont Bruins* | L 54-67 | 10-10 | C. Day 15 | K. Hollins 3 | L. McCauley 6 |
| February 2, 2040 | @ Drake Bulldogs* | L 55-83 | 10-11 | C. Day 12 | K. Hollins 5 | L. McCauley 6 |
| February 6, 2040 | @ Southern Illinois Salukis* | L 62-73 | 10-12 | K. Hollins 16 | K. Hollins 3 | H. Murphy 5 |
| February 9, 2040 |  EVANSVILLE PURPLE ACES* | W 82-64 | 11-12 | E. Carstensen 14 | K. Hollins 9 | L. McCauley 8 |
| February 13, 2040 | MISSOURI STATE BEARS* | W 85-70 | 12-12 | J. Farnsworth 14 | K. Hollins 5 | C. Day 7 |
| February 16, 2040 | ILLINOIS STATE REDBIRDS* | W 79-62 | 13-12 | K. Hollins 17 | K. Hollins 4 | E. Carstensen 9 |
| February 20, 2040 | @ Northern Iowa Panthers* | L 58-82 | 13-13 | M. Lyles 13 | K. Hollins 3 | I. Harrison 7 |
| February 23, 2040 | @ Evansville Purple Aces* | L 58-81 | 13-14 | J. Farnsworth 13 | K. Hollins 10 | C. Day 7 |
| February 27, 2040 | @ Indiana State Sycamores* | L 66-71 | 13-15 | L. McCauley 13 | K. Hollins 5 | E. Carstensen 8 |
| March 2, 2040 |  UIC FLAMES* | L 64-80 | 13-16 | E. Carstensen 15 | J. Farnsworth 4 | E. Carstensen 8 |
| March 6, 2040 | INDIANA STATE SYCAMORES  MVC Tournament | L 80-83 | 13-17 | L. Rucker 14 | K. Hollins 4 | E. Carstensen 5 |
